The mystery of the front row

Wherever lectures happen, regardless of the size of the venue, most of the front row will be empty. Even when the lecture hall is standing room only (should I be so lucky), many of the seats up front will be peopleless. In this photo from a lecture I gave years ago you can see people standing, literally with their backs against the wall, instead of taking a seat in the front.

The empty front rowNow at a rock concert, or sporting event, people would sell their children to get a front row seat. The only time I had front row seats at a basketball game it cost me $300 and I had to watch two sucky teams: for good teams there were no front row seats available. The front row is usually the bees knees: what’s going on?

My theory is the following:

  • We like the freedom to be bored. In the front, there’s nowhere to hide. If we want to nap, pick our nose, read e-mail, we can’t without feeling embarassed. If the speaker is bad, we’re stuck, for an hour or more, in living hell.
  • We’re taught in school to go for the back. People in the front get called on by teachers. Most of us hated that, so we hide ourselves in the middle rows.
  • We have low confidence in public speakers. We’re pretty sure it’s not going to be all that good, and we want the option to leave quickly without embarassing ourselves.
  • The front row feels like part of the show. Sitting within a few feet feels like you are on stage yourself, a feeling most people don’t like. Some people also fear being picked as a volunteer which seems more likely in the front.

I suppose it’s a sign of a speaker with a good reputation when people confidently sit in the risky front row.

This diagram below from cartoon phdcomics offers several other theories about where people sit. My favorite part of their analysis is the proximity to lecturer formula, that divides how much you care by how tired you are. Perhaps it would be more accurate to measure how committed you are to the speaker. If you’re 100% convinced you need to listen to the entire lecture, you want the best experience possible. If you’re not sure, or if you’re at an event with multiple tracks, you want the ability to change your mind.

In Confessions of a Public Speaker, in chapter 4 on how to work a tough room.  I explain a technique for balancing rooms. I’d never let an audience stay in the formation shown in the picture above. Instead I’d ask everyone to move forward and close the ranks, forming an actual audience.

Paolo_IX14_front_row

(Photo by Paolo Malabuyo, at IXDA14)

14 Responses to “The mystery of the front row”

  1. kia

    I never sit in the front row because every time I do, one of the following happens:

    * The speaker gets too close to the front row during the presentation and talks over my head to the mass of the audience behind me, so I have to crane my head around to see them. (Note the poor fellow twisted around in the front row in your shot above, as the speaker addresses the mass of people sitting in the back and the middle of the room.)

    * The speaker actually sits or stands on a chair in the front row at some point during the presentation, so I must awkwardly sit next to them while they sit or kneel on the seat next to me, addressing everyone sitting behind me.

    * It turns out the front row was reserved for videotaping/special attendees/whathaveyou and I’m asked to move when all the rest of the seats have filled up.

    So I sit in the second row. At least then I can put my feet up on the empty chair in the front row.

    Reply
  2. Glen Gordon

    Another reason those people might be standing in the back is that they came in late. Out of courtesy they decide not to distract the whole room or you by walking across the front and plopping into a seat. But also notice the buffer zones. When people are not assigned seats (as at a sporting event or theater or even an airplane) they like to leave a buffer zone of one or sometimes even two seats on their left and right. This also creates a situation where the latecomers don’t want to have to step across someone to get to a seat, ironically eliminating the buffer zone in the process. I always encourage my audiences, 5 minutes before I start my presentations, to slide over and eliminate the buffer zone, or prepare to be crossed over by the newcomers until their row is full. :-)

    Reply
  3. Steven Harris

    Another: We’re self-conscious. If you’re in the front, lots of people behind you can look at you (much like the speaker, but unintentionally so), but you can’t see what’s happening with the rest of the audience. There’s less sense of being in the crowd, able to share in the collectively approved response to the singular speaker.

    Reply
    • Franklin Chen

      I am very conscious of my seating preferences in many situations. Overall I like sitting in the back and at the side so that I can see everything that is happening. Also, I don’t like getting distracted by latecomers (or leavers) making noises behind me. In the case of microphones and slide presentations, I don’t like being blasted or not being able to see because of view too wide.

      That said, at a concert last night, I sat in the second row. (Nobody sat in the front row, except some very latecomers who came in during a break.) A completely, totally different kind of event from a lecture.

      Reply
      • Scott

        Franklin: you make a good point. Many rooms are designed for the optimal seat to be 5 rows back.

        A key metric might also be the distance from the speaker to the first row: if it’s less than 5 feet it feels awkward to be so close. If the front row is 15 feet back I suspect it’d be filled more often.

        Reply
  4. Scott (admin)

    Good answers all – I think Mr. Harris’s answer hits a reason I have but hadn’t though about – I like to feel like I’m in the audience and you lose that upfront.

    Reply
  5. roseg

    2 more ideas:

    Idea 1: The people who arrive early always leave the front row(s) empty because of idea 2. The room starts to fill up. By the time the stragglers arrive they’re too embarrassed to walk past a sea of people to get to the front (especially if they’re late – after the talk has started – and will be seen by colleagues as well as the speaker who may be offended or glare at them). Sitting at the front also means you can’t easily sneak out when the going gets boring.

    Idea 2: Unlike music or theatre, the rules of engagement re conference presentations, school lectures and stand up comedy can be very unpredictable. The presenter may at any point pick on you or ask you a question or use you to illustrate something. If you’ve ever seen Dame Edna’s work, you’ll understand why no-one in their right mind would request a “good” seat.

    Cheers :-)

    r

    Reply
  6. jcopenha

    Actually, I beleive you recommend standing in the back. One of your essays on attending profressional conferences mentioned it.

    Reply
  7. Phil

    All very good theories.

    My personal one is that people, or more typically men, don’t like people to be behind them. It’s a psychological thing about the threat of attack from behind. If you sit in the middle or even at the back, there are less people who may attack you without you knowing. We all know that the chances of being attacked from behind at a talk are slim. However psychological influences run deep. Just a theory!

    In a similar vein, in a restaurant men like to set at the back of the restaurant with their back to the wall. In this way they can see what is going on and preempt any attack on their loved one(s). Lastly, men typically like to sleep nearest the door in case they need to jump up and defend the family from attack.

    Reply
  8. robert gal

    personally, I never sit into to first row, because…. I fear, that the speaker will ask me a question…
    yes, that happens all the time, … if the speaker want’s to communicate with the audience, he usually asks a question…and who will he choose to answer?…right, someone from the first row.
    The everybody would watch, what I’m answering…

    I don’t want to be used like a speaker’s tool (because they try to demonstrate their theory at the most of the time)

    that’s all.

    Reply
  9. Stacked Stone

    I think it’s a school thing and we want to avoid being dragged up in public.

    Reply
  10. Jared M. Spool

    We found that when we put a row of tables in front of the front row, the seats get used effectively. Add power strips and every seat will be taken.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

* Required